Democratic state needs a democratic civil society and vice versa

Violation of democratic rights

  • NGOs and CSOs activities include – working for the poor and the marginalized, might involve questioning and protesting decisions taken by the government. There were instances where some CSOs and NGOs disagreeing certain government policies, for instance, opposing nuclear power plants, instances of campaigning to the right to food etc.

  • Members and representatives of civil society organisations advocate that it is the right of the democratically elected government to protect the right of the citizens to protest. However, by targeting them as anti-nationals, they emphasised that the government was violating two democratic rights: the right to freedom of expression including the right to protest, and the right to form associations.

  • Civil society as the sphere of associational life forms the backbone of democracy. Apart from right to participate in elections, citizens have the right to scrutinise the work of their representatives, publicize acts of omission and commission, such as infringement of civil liberties, appropriation of tribal land for purposes of accumulation, failure of governments to provide a reasonable standard of life for the citizens, and engage with leaders on the troubled issue of political conflicts.

  • The right to engage with, interrogate and criticise representatives is an integral part of democracy. Without this right, democracy becomes farcical, an empty term, a phantom concept, an illusion.

Democracy beyond elections

  • Democracy is ultimately not only about the rights of the people who vote representatives into power but also right to speak back to abuse of power. There has been too much emphasis on democracy as elections in India. The heat needs to be taken off elections.

  • There is a need to be conscious of what happens between elections, given the opacity of government, given its awesome power over the lives and liberties of citizens, and given the propensity of every government to appropriate, accumulate and misuse power.

  • This can be checked, provided we appreciate the competence of ordinary people to participate in political campaigns in civil society.

Rise of civil society

  • The focus on civil society dates back to the 1980s, when political scientists began to speak of a ‘crisis of representation’. Citizens across the world had shifted from older and traditional forms of representation, such as political parties and trade unions, to ‘newer’ modes: social movements, informal citizen groups and non-governmental organisations.

  • The worldwide shift to civil society was catalysed by the mobilisation of people against Stalinist states in Eastern and Central Europe in the 1970s and the 1980s. Citizens turned their back on unresponsive and authoritarian states and formed associations, such as reading clubs and soup kitchens, in a metaphorical space outside the state. This space they called civil society, a companion concept to democracy.

  • In India, by the late 1970s, the decline of all institutions gave rise to several mass-based political movements and grassroots activism. The anti-caste movement, the struggle for gender justice, the movement for civil liberties, for a sound environment, and against mega development projects that have displaced thousands of poor tribals and hill dwellers, the movement against child labour, for the right to information, for shelter, for primary education, and for food security have mobilised in civil society.

  • The fact that vital issues related to livelihoods, to the fulfilment of basic needs, and for justice were not taken up by political parties but by civil society organisations acted to propel hopes in civil society as an alternative to the non-performing state and an unresponsive party system.

  • In the first decade of the 21st century, civil society organisations stepped in to represent the interests of the most deprived and the most marginalised in the country. Mobilisation proved effective, and the enactment of social rights followed a number of civil society campaigns, the filing of Public Interest Litigations in the Supreme Court, and the onset of a new phase of judicial activism.

  • However, today, we see the marginalisation of civil society and the sidelining of a rights-based approach to social policy.

  • From 2004 to 2014, civil society organisations came together to press upon the government the right of citizens to social goods. Once laws granting the right to information, to food, and to work had been passed, activists kept watch on acts of omission and commission, and issued citizen reports.

  • Today, social security plans are announced without corresponding mobilisation of, consultation with or intervention of civil society organisations. On the contrary, the government has come down heavily on organisations by blocking their bank accounts, by putting a stop to funding, and by casting aspersions on their ability to represent the people of India. In many instances, non-governmental organisations such as Greenpeace have been projected as being anti-national.

Conclusion:

  • A democratic state needs a democratic civil society. But a democratic civil society also needs a democratic state; a state that respects the politics of ‘voice’ as opposed to the politics of the ‘vote’. If the government respects the voice of citizens through the grant of the right to freedom of expression and association, it should be enabling civil society to articulate aspirations, critically engage with the state, and issue social report cards. The promises of democracy can only be realised through collective action in civil society. If the state constrains civil society space, democracy is truncated, and citizens are seen only as voters. They are deprived of status.

  • Civil society and voluntary sector occupy a prominent place in the democratic landscape of India. Their contribution in helping the state reaching out to the poor and giving voice to the common citizens can’t be overstated. However, rule of law must govern their functioning in matters of financing and objectives.

Source:TH

Leave a Reply